09:59 <leon-p> hmm... not sure I really like the recent changes w.r.t. setting the tiled state of programs. It kinda defeats the purpose of CSD mode.

10:04 <ifreund> leon-p: I think setting tiled state for floating windows is an abuse of the protocol...

10:05 <leon-p> I was actually talking about setting tiled for tiled views :D

10:05 <leon-p> it makes CSD windows look funky in layouts with gaps

10:06 <leon-p> maybe this is something the layout generator can set for individual windows eventually

10:06 <ifreund> some maybe, but other behave much better

10:06 <ifreund> for example mpv locks itself to a specific aspect ratio if tiled mode is not set

10:07 <ifreund> yeah, I think it would be reasonable to allow the layout generator to override this eventually

10:08 <leon-p> Well, I initially added CSD mode, because I explicitly wanted the typical GTK look in GTK applications, including rounded corners and drop-shadows, which right now only works if they are floating. So I would appreciate that.

10:14 <ifreund> yeah, I can totally understand wanting gtk to have drop shadows when there are gaps

10:15 <leon-p> would be pretty cool if it switched based on whether there are gaps, yeah

10:23 <ifreund> yeah, I think mpv is actually pretty ok in the layout even if we don't set the tiled state

10:23 <ifreund> gtk drop shadows with no gaps would be the bigger problem I think