<ocdtrekkie>
Ah I figured it out, my cable modem's port forward was at issue.
<ocdtrekkie>
Server was happy, just wasn't getting traffic to it.
<ocdtrekkie>
My cable modem is in a double NAT setup, which is fine, except my router is technically on DHCP from the modem, and it grabbed a different address for the first time ever.
<ocdtrekkie>
So now I have a DHCP registration for it so it won't move and mess up my port forward.